"Zero immigration is pure fancy"

OECD Directorate for Employment, Labour and Social Affairs

Legal immigration may be desirable, but can illegal immigration be controlled or even eliminated? Jean-Pierre Garson, OECD's expert on international migration, responded to questions from Marc Semo for the French daily, Libération.*

Marc Semo: What is the scale of illegal immigration in Western countries?

Jean-Pierre Garson: By definition, it is impossible to give an exact figure, though some countries still make official estimates. The United States, for example, reckons that it has 5 to 6 million illegal immigrants. There are no comparable figures for the European Union (EU), but the number can be gauged from the results of the regularisation programmes implemented in recent years in several EU countries.

In Spain, the situation of 120 000 illegal immigrants has been regularised; in Italy, 250 000 applications have been made; and in France, 80 000 people had their situations regularised in June 1997. These figures need to be weighed against the criteria adopted by different governments, but it is clear that everywhere there are far fewer illegal immigrants than some of the fanciful estimates would have it. Illegal immigrants move around a lot, some simply pass through, others stay no more than a few months. And the fact that the unemployment rate for immigrants is two to three times higher than the national average is hardly an incentive for people to come into a country, even if there are labour shortages in some sectors.

MS: Who are the illegal immigrants?

JPG: Their profile varies according to where they want to go. Those choosing southern countries of the EU tend to fill unskilled jobs in agriculture and construction, or to work as domestics. Those in northern Europe are mainly asylum-seekers, as in Germany, though this category has fallen steeply, from 438 000 asylum-seekers nine years ago to 80 000 last year. In the United Kingdom, asylum applications peaked at nearly 100 000 last year. On average, the proportion of successful asylum requests is very low, and it sometimes takes two to three years, as in the United Kingdom, for an application to get through.

In the meantime, UK-based asylum-seekers receive state benefits and can take advantage of the opportunities that arise in what is, after all, a flexible and dynamic economy. Moreover, immigrants do not get stopped in the street and asked to show their identity papers, as they themselves would point out.

MS: How do illegal immigrants get into a country?

JPG: The public tends to focus on heroic stories (some ending tragically) or on spectacular beach landings. The truth is that many immigrants enter legally on tourist visas. This is the case both for the United States and Europe. Those with such visas scatter about the country and are not easy to locate, but they represent a major (if not the major) part of immigration flows. Immigrants may also find themselves in illegal situations for purely administrative reasons. Some may have a residence permit but no work permit; to make a living, they have no choice but to work illegally. There are others whose residence permit has not been renewed or who are caught out by changes in the law.

MS: Is there a link between legal immigration and illegal immigration?

JPG: Once a flow of emigration to a country starts, it encourages others back home to join in. These people may wait their turn patiently, but if the pressure or desire to go is strong, they may try their luck at illegal ways of getting into the country, especially if they have family or friends already there. But that apart there is no direct link between the two types of immigration.

MS: Is it possible to halt these flows?

JPG: It is absurd to talk about an impenetrable "Fortress Europe"”, as some people do. The figures tell us that. But while it is true that the EU has not taken in as many immigrants recently as in the thirty expansionary years after World War II, it has still allowed a lot in. France, for example, has taken in 80-100 000 a year over the past decade. Germany took in 1 million a year between 1989 and 1992, although these included many ethnic Germans from the ex-Soviet bloc. In a small country like Denmark, the foreign population now represents more than 5% of the total population, compared with only 1% as little as eight years ago. The countries of southern Europe, where emigration was the norm as recently as 15 years ago, have become countries of immigration. Some politicians shy away from these issues for fear of losing votes, but the facts speak for themselves: zero immigration is just pure fancy.

* This article appears courtesy of Libération newspaper, where it originally appeared in French as "L'immigration zéro est une pure utopie", on 26 February 2001. 


• OECD, Trends in International Migration 2000, 2001. 

©OECD Observer No 225, March 2001  

Economic data

GDP growth: +0.6% Q1 2019 year-on-year
Consumer price inflation: 2.3% May 2019 annual
Trade: +0.4% exp, -1.2% imp, Q1 2019
Unemployment: 5.2% July 2019
Last update: 8 July 2019

OECD Observer Newsletter

Stay up-to-date with the latest news from the OECD by signing up for our e-newsletter :

Twitter feed

Subscribe now

<b>Subscribe now!</b>

To order your own paper editions,email Observer@OECD.org

Online edition
Previous editions

Don't miss

  • MCM logo
  • The following communiqué and Chair’s statement were issued at the close of the OECD Council Meeting at Ministerial level, this year presided by the Slovak Republic.
  • Food production will suffer some of the most immediate and brutal effects of climate change, with some regions of the world suffering far more than others. Only through unhindered global trade can we ensure that high-quality, nutritious food reaches those who need it most, Angel Gurría, Secretary-General of the OECD, and José Graziano da Silva, Director-General of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization, write in their latest Project Syndicate article. Read the article here.
  • Globalisation will continue and get stronger, and how to harness it is the great challenge, says OECD Secretary-General Gurría on Bloomberg TV. Watch the interview here.
  • OECD Secretary-General Angel Gurría with UN Secretary-General António Guterres at the 73rd Session of the UN General Assembly, in New York City.
  • The new OECD Observer Crossword, with Myles Mellor. Try it online!
  • Listen to the "Robots are coming for our jobs" episode of The Guardian's "Chips with Everything podcast", in which The Guardian’s economics editor, Larry Elliott, and Jeremy Wyatt, a professor of robotics and artificial intelligence at the University of Birmingham, and Jordan Erica Webber, freelance journalist, discuss the findings of the new OECD report "Automation, skills use and training". Listen here.
  • Do we really know the difference between right and wrong? Alison Taylor of BSR and Susan Hawley of Corruption Watch tell us why it matters to play by the rules. Watch the recording of our Facebook live interview here.
  • Has public decision-making been hijacked by a privileged few? Watch the recording of our Facebook live interview with Stav Shaffir, MK (Zionist Union) Chair of the Knesset Committee on Transparency here.
  • Can a nudge help us make more ethical decisions? Watch the recording of our Facebook live interview with Saugatto Datta, managing director at ideas42 here.
  • The fight against tax evasion is gaining further momentum as Barbados, Côte d’Ivoire, Jamaica, Malaysia, Panama and Tunisia signed the BEPS Multilateral Convention on 24 January, bringing the total number of signatories to 78. The Convention strengthens existing tax treaties and reduces opportunities for tax avoidance by multinational enterprises.
  • Globalisation’s many benefits have been unequally shared, and public policy has struggled to keep up with a rapidly-shifting world. The OECD is working alongside governments and international organisations to help improve and harness the gains while tackling the root causes of inequality, and ensuring a level playing field globally. Please watch.
  • Checking out the job situation with the OECD scoreboard of labour market performances: do you want to know how your country compares with neighbours and competitors on income levels or employment?
  • Trade is an important point of focus in today’s international economy. This video presents facts and statistics from OECD’s most recent publications on this topic.
  • The OECD Gender Initiative examines existing barriers to gender equality in education, employment, and entrepreneurship. The gender portal monitors the progress made by governments to promote gender equality in both OECD and non-OECD countries and provides good practices based on analytical tools and reliable data.
  • Interested in a career in Paris at the OECD? The OECD is a major international organisation, with a mission to build better policies for better lives. With our hub based in one of the world's global cities and offices across continents, find out more at www.oecd.org/careers .
  • Visit the OECD Gender Data Portal. Selected indicators shedding light on gender inequalities in education, employment and entrepreneurship.

Most Popular Articles

OECD Insights Blog

NOTE: All signed articles in the OECD Observer express the opinions of the authors
and do not necessarily represent the official views of OECD member countries.

All rights reserved. OECD 2019