Quality apprenticeships: The new degree?

More policymakers are looking beyond tertiary education to apprenticeships as a possible way of strengthening the labour market and improving job prospects for the young. But not any apprenticeship will do.

©Christopher Furlong/Getty Images/AFP

Under the guild system in medieval Europe, a journeyman was someone who, having finished his seven-year apprenticeship, travelled from town to town offering his services for a day’s wages (hence “journeyman” from the French “journée”, meaning a day). After a few years of this itinerant life, he might submit a “masterpiece” to the relevant guild, whose members would evaluate his work and decide whether to admit him to the guild and confer the title of “master” upon him.

A young person starting out today might never get a chance to present a masterpiece. The statistics are harrowing. The OECD estimates that around 20% of young people in Italy, Mexico and Spain are neither working nor in education and training. In Greece and Turkey that figure rises to 27%. In desperation over their repeated failure to find a job, many young people give up. Others continue on the treadmill of internships, and are often unpaid, despite the fact that they carry out the same tasks as their salaried colleagues.

Governments are beginning to give serious attention to apprenticeships as an answer to high (and increasingly longterm) unemployment. The three European countries which proved most resilient to the 2008 downturn all have strong traditions of apprenticeships. Germany, Austria and Switzerland register less than 9% youth unemployment, compared to the OECD average of just over 16%. The success of Germany’s dual education system has aroused the interest of its stricken neighbours. Students in Germany can opt for one or two days a week of vocational training alongside regular schooling. Part of this training occurs in the workplace, for which apprentices are paid about one-third of a trained worker’s salary. Earlier in 2013, Greece, Italy, Latvia, Portugal, the Slovak Republic and Spain signed memoranda with Germany to help them develop similar systems. No one is suggesting that apprenticeships alone can resolve the crisis, but more countries now believe they can do a lot to help. In June, the OECD included apprenticeships as one of the key points in its Action Plan for Youth. The G20 countries (consisting of the world’s largest economies) have also called for greater investment in apprenticeships.

A fair question to ask is: why did it take so long? Germany, for example, introduced its dual education system in 1969. One reason is bias. University education has long been vaunted as a secure route to financial stability and personal fulfilment. Young people in vocational training are often stigmatised as being “not quite up to” the rigours of academia. This prejudice has cowed many young people into pursuing university studies for which they have neither the inclination nor the flair, and discouraged them from the more satisfying alternatives. Governments should abandon their absolutism towards university education and instead encourage young people with the desire to enter an apprenticeship, and they should focus especially on young school leavers, who are more than twice as likely to be unemployed than university graduates.

One successful initiative–and one that aims beyond traditional apprenticeships in manufacturing, for instance–is the UK’s £25 million apprenticeship scheme to train young people, while paying them, as commercial pilots, lawyers, engineers  and accountants. These “higher level” apprenticeships are on par with university programmes. Companies will also benefit. Europe’s aviation sector, for instance, will need 92 500 pilots by 2030. The UK scheme has caught on. In 2012, some 3,700 people were in higher apprenticeships, a 68% increase from the previous year. The plan also aims to bring under-represented groups, such as women, into such professions.

The scheme is successful in part because it established apprenticeships in fields without such traditions, and in which future job growth is likely.

 In the United States, the US Office for Apprenticeships provides seed capital to companies to develop training programmes in high-growth industries, such as information technology, health care, biotechnology and geospatial technology. In 2007, high-growth industries accounted for 46% of newly registered programmes, with 30% of all apprentices enrolled in them.

But for apprenticeships to spread through more countries, a number of obstacles need to be overcome, such as a lack of certification and rigid age restrictions, which effectively block apprentices from switching career paths or entering university, should they so choose. Employers may be reluctant to invest in apprenticeships because they fear their apprentices will be “poached” by other firms, and so may instead offer only internships and other short-term contracts. Firms may even claim that these are legitimate training programmes when they are nothing of the sort. Italy addressed this abuse of confidence in 2011 by setting the duration of apprenticeships at a mandatory six-month minimum to make them worthwhile, and at a three-year maximum to ensure that employers do not exploit apprentices by arbitrarily prolonging their training. Should a firm wish to hire an apprentice, it must have a record of hiring at least 50% of those it has trained in the past. This way, companies can tap into the skills pool only if they have already put something into it. In Australia, apprentices are certified as soon as they have demonstrated their competence in their chosen area, rather than when they have completed a stipulated training period.

Given the costs, companies could be more likely to offer apprenticeships if labour unions and the government share the burden. In Germany, for instance, social partners work together to set professional standards and exams, which are formally issued by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Technology, and determine apprentices’ salaries through collective wage negotiations. Canada and France relieve some of the pressure on employers through tax credits. France also gives additional social security exemptions to employers, especially those employing a disadvantaged or disabled young person.

In the best of times, government cash no doubt helps. But it is one thing to finance apprenticeships when there are jobs to be had, and another when youth unemployment spirals into the millions. Can governments afford to finance an entire generation?

Labour reforms that help create jobs would help pave the way forward and are at least as important as government support. Let’s not forget that Germany’s strong tradition of apprenticeship did not prevent it from being labelled the “sick man of Europe” in the 1990s. However, labour market reforms since then have been part of its recent successes. The OECD cautions that attempts to skirt serious reform through the adoption of early retirement schemes in a bid to open up jobs to young people won’t work: the costs are heavy and the benefits few. Until the social bias towards university qualifications is removed and policymakers restore dignity to “vocational training”, an unacceptable number of young people will be locked out of rewarding and productive jobs. With quality apprenticeships, tomorrow’s journeymen (and women) will have that chance to learn and work in promising careers, and who knows, become “masters”, too.

Lyndon Thompson

For more information, contact Mark Keese at the OECD.

References

OECD (2013), The OECD Action Plan for Youth, www.oecd.org/els/emp/Youth-Action-Plan.pdf

The Economist (2013).“Ein neuer Deal? –Germany’s vaunted dual-education system is its latest export hit”, The Economist

BBC News (2012), “Apprenticeships scheme to train pilots and lawyers”

“Apprentices ‘more employable’ – survey”, BBC News

© OECD Observer No 295 Q2 2013




Economic data

GDP growth: +0.6% Q4 2017 year-on-year
Consumer price inflation: 2.6% May 2018 annual
Trade: +2.7% exp, +3.0% imp, Q4 2017
Unemployment: 5.4% Mar 2018
Last update: 06 Jul 2018

E-Newsletter

Stay up-to-date with the latest news from the OECD by signing up for our e-newsletter :

Twitter feed

Suscribe now

<b>Subscribe now!</b>

To receive your exclusive paper editions delivered to you directly


Online edition
Previous editions

Don't miss

  • Watch the webcast of the final press conference of the OECD annual ministerial meeting 2018.
  • International co-operation, inclusive growth and digitalisation lead the themes of the 2018 OECD Forum in Paris on 29-30 May, under the banner of What brings us together www.oecd.org/forum. It is held alongside the annual OECD Ministerial Council Meeting on 30-31 May, chaired this year by France with a focus on multilateralism www.oecd.org/mcm.
  • Listen to the "Robots are coming for our jobs" episode of The Guardian's "Chips with Everything podcast", in which The Guardian’s economics editor, Larry Elliott, and Jeremy Wyatt, a professor of robotics and artificial intelligence at the University of Birmingham, and Jordan Erica Webber, freelance journalist, discuss the findings of the new OECD report "Automation, skills use and training". Listen here.
  • Do we really know the difference between right and wrong? Alison Taylor of BSR and Susan Hawley of Corruption Watch tell us why it matters to play by the rules. Watch the recording of our Facebook live interview here.
  • Has public decision-making been hijacked by a privileged few? Watch the recording of our Facebook live interview with Stav Shaffir, MK (Zionist Union) Chair of the Knesset Committee on Transparency here.
  • Can a nudge help us make more ethical decisions? Watch the recording of our Facebook live interview with Saugatto Datta, managing director at ideas42 here.
  • Ambassador Aleksander Surdej, Permanent Representative of Poland to the OECD, was a guest on France 24’s English-language show “The Debate”, where he discussed French President Emmanuel Macron’s speech at the World Economic Forum in Davos.
  • The fight against tax evasion is gaining further momentum as Barbados, Côte d’Ivoire, Jamaica, Malaysia, Panama and Tunisia signed the BEPS Multilateral Convention on 24 January, bringing the total number of signatories to 78. The Convention strengthens existing tax treaties and reduces opportunities for tax avoidance by multinational enterprises.
  • Rousseau
  • Do you trust your government? The OECD’s How's life 2017 report finds that only 38% of people in OECD countries trust their government. How can we improve our old "Social contract?" Read more.
  • Papers show “past coming back to haunt us”: OECD Secretary-General Angel Gurria tells Sky News that the so-called "Paradise Papers" show a past coming back to haunt us, but one which is now being dismantled. Please watch the video.
  • When someone asks me to describe an ideal girl, in my head, she is a person who is physically and mentally independent, brave to speak her mind, treated with respect just like she treats others, and inspiring to herself and others. But I know that the reality is still so much different. By Alda, 18, on International Day of the Girl. Read more.
  • Globalisation’s many benefits have been unequally shared, and public policy has struggled to keep up with a rapidly-shifting world. The OECD is working alongside governments and international organisations to help improve and harness the gains while tackling the root causes of inequality, and ensuring a level playing field globally. Please watch.
  • Read some of the insightful remarks made at OECD Forum 2017, held on 6-7 June. OECD Forum kick-started events with a focus on inclusive growth, digitalisation, and trust, under the overall theme of Bridging Divides.
  • Checking out the job situation with the OECD scoreboard of labour market performances: do you want to know how your country compares with neighbours and competitors on income levels or employment?
  • Trade is an important point of focus in today’s international economy. This video presents facts and statistics from OECD’s most recent publications on this topic.
  • The OECD Gender Initiative examines existing barriers to gender equality in education, employment, and entrepreneurship. The gender portal monitors the progress made by governments to promote gender equality in both OECD and non-OECD countries and provides good practices based on analytical tools and reliable data.
  • Interested in a career in Paris at the OECD? The OECD is a major international organisation, with a mission to build better policies for better lives. With our hub based in one of the world's global cities and offices across continents, find out more at www.oecd.org/careers .
  • Visit the OECD Gender Data Portal. Selected indicators shedding light on gender inequalities in education, employment and entrepreneurship.

Most Popular Articles

OECD Insights Blog

NOTE: All signed articles in the OECD Observer express the opinions of the authors
and do not necessarily represent the official views of OECD member countries.

All rights reserved. OECD 2018